A member of Day Air Credit Union, who we’ll call Mike, contacted us recently about a potential scam he was encountering on Facebook Marketplace. Mike likes to list computers and gaming systems on sites like Facebook Marketplace, E-Bay, Let It Go, etc. Mike listed an expensive gaming console on Facebook Marketplace for $800. Shortly after listing the unit, Mike received an inquiry from a buyer who was eager to purchase and wanted to make arrangements to send an “official check” for payment. The buyer said to Mike, “I know you will not send the item until the check clears,” so Mike figured that everything was on the “up and up” with such an honest comment and he thought there’s no way an “official check” could be a problem, right? When the check arrived, the amount was for $50 more than the actual purchase price. When Mike contacted the buyer about the overpayment, the buyer apologized for the mistake and asked Mike if he could send back the overpayment by check to his shipping address.

Fortunately for Mike, he did not send the overpayment back or cash the check. The $850 “official check” was in fact counterfeit. The scammer was really just trying to get Mike to send $50 for the supposed overpayment. Many people fall victim to this overpayment scam because the amount the scammer asks for, $50 in this case, is a small amount compared to the actual price of the item. Many folks will just go ahead and send the payment without thinking anything of it. Then when then big check bounces, there is a real problem. We are glad that Mike reached out before doing anything with the check. He was able to report the transaction to the US Postal Inspection Service and Federal Trade Commission (FTC). Overpayment scams are growing in popularity in the US.

There are other variations of these over payment scams. Always trust your instincts. If something seems “phishy” or “too good to be true”, it probably is. Below are a couple of numbers you can refer to if you are ever suspicious of a similar situation.

US Postal Inspection Service: 1-877-876-2455

FTC: 1-877-382-4357

Checking Accounts

Premium Perks

Freedom Checking

CashBack Checking

Direct Deposit


Savings Accounts

Savings Accounts

Super Saver

Money Market





Debit Card

Low Rate Credit Card

Rewards Credit Card

CU Rewards

Card Controls


Mobile Deposit

Online Banking

Pay Someone


Compare Rates

Vehicle Loans

Auto Loans

Refinance Your Car

Motorcycle & Jet Ski Loans

Boat & RV Loans

Mortgage & Home Loans


Refinance Your House

Home Equity Loans

Construction Loans


Personal Loans


StretchPay Loans

Student Loans

Credit Cards


Apply for a Loan

Pay a Loan

Online Bill Pay

Chat With Us

Financial Planning



Estate Planning

401(k) Rollover

Retirement Planning

Day Air Insurance

Auto Insurance

Home Insurance

Identity Theft Protection

Life Insurance

More Products & Services


Financial Counseling

Credit Reports

Reorder Checks


Online Banking

Online Banking

Online Bill Pay

Login to Online Banking

Mobile Banking

Mobile Banking

Mobile Deposit

Pay Someone

Text Banking


Apply for a Loan

Pay a Loan


Mobile Pay

Chat With Us


Business Checking

Business Savings

Business Certificates


Business Debit Card

Business Credit Card


Commercial Loans

Term Loans

PPP Loans

Line of Credit


Business Bill Pay


Online Business Banking

Login to Business Banking

Login to PIB MLO

Business Banking App

Join Day Air

Why Choose Day Air

Membership Eligibility

Annual Member Savings

Compare Rates

Join Day Air


Community Involvement

Financial Education

Dayton VA Medical Center

Dayton Dragons

Contests & Sweepstakes


Press & News

Newsletters & Reports



Helpful Resources